Spider-Man version · Film
Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man
Sam Raimi's Peter: the only live-action Spider-Man who never used web-shooters.
Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man 2 (2004), Spider-Man 3 (2007), Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021).
Against the 49 opponents on this site, Maguire's Peter is favored in 23 fights, a toss-up in 12, the underdog in 5 and a long shot in 9. Against the whole original Sinister Six at once: 14%. Against all six one after another: 4%. Overall, this version is rated −4 points against classic Peter Parker.
About this Spider-Man
Tobey Maguire played Peter Parker in Sam Raimi's trilogy: Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man 2 (2004) and Spider-Man 3 (2007). His Peter spins webs from his own body rather than using web-shooters, and fought the Green Goblin, Doctor Octopus, Sandman and Venom. He returned, older and wiser, in Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021).
Fight rules: both fighters at their peak, no preparation, no allies, only their own powers and personal gear. A win is a knockout, a restraint they can't escape, or a forced surrender. The percentages are fan estimates, not official information.
Powers
Spider strength and endurance, organic web spinnerets in his wrists, and a spider-sense shown as slow-motion perception.
Gear
None. His webbing is organic.
Signature feats
Stopped a runaway elevated train with his webs and body (Spider-Man 2). Beat the Green Goblin hand to hand (2002), talked Doc Ock into drowning his own reactor (2004), beat Sandman with water and Venom with the noise of clanging metal pipes (Spider-Man 3).
Weaknesses
Emotional turmoil once made his powers fail (Spider-Man 2). In the black suit he turned aggressive.
Fighting style
A brawler-acrobat with little formal training and a lot of heart.
Power set
- Spider-strength6/10
Stopped a runaway train.
- Organic webbing7/10
Web spinnerets in his wrists.
- Spider-sense7/10
Slow-motion danger perception.
- Agility9/10
Superb acrobatics.
Stats
Odds against every opponent
Maguire's Peter's chance of winning each one-on-one fight. Each name links to the full matchup.
| Opponent | Spidey wins | Bar | Outcome | Matchup modifier |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Doctor Octopus Original Sinister Six | 53% | Toss-up | +2: He has fought an Otto Octavius before and knows how tentacles move. | |
| Vulture Original Sinister Six | 83% | Favored | ||
| Electro Original Sinister Six | 51% | Toss-up | ||
| Kraven the Hunter Original Sinister Six | 51% | Toss-up | ||
| Mysterio Original Sinister Six | 70% | Favored | −2: Emotional pressure once took his powers away, so a mind-game specialist has an opening. | |
| Sandman Original Sinister Six | 56% | Toss-up | +3: He has beaten a Sandman with water.; +2: Train-stopping strength and stamina keep him standing against heavy hitters. | |
| Green Goblin Spider-Man rogue | 58% | Toss-up | +2: He has survived Norman's glider and pumpkin bombs before. | |
| Hobgoblin Spider-Man rogue | 61% | Favored | ||
| Venom Spider-Man rogue | 42% | Toss-up | +4: He has beaten Venom by turning sound on the symbiote.; +2: Train-stopping strength and stamina keep him standing against heavy hitters. | |
| Carnage Spider-Man rogue | 28% | Underdog | +2: Train-stopping strength and stamina keep him standing against heavy hitters. | |
| Kingpin Spider-Man rogue | 77% | Favored | ||
| Lizard Spider-Man rogue | 56% | Toss-up | ||
| Rhino Spider-Man rogue | 68% | Favored | +2: Train-stopping strength and stamina keep him standing against heavy hitters. | |
| Scorpion Spider-Man rogue | 67% | Favored | ||
| Shocker Spider-Man rogue | 83% | Favored | ||
| Chameleon Spider-Man rogue | 88% | Favored | ||
| Mister Negative Spider-Man rogue | 61% | Favored | ||
| Morbius Spider-Man rogue | 67% | Favored | ||
| Morlun Spider-Man rogue | 14% | Long shot | +2: Train-stopping strength and stamina keep him standing against heavy hitters. | |
| Black Cat Spider-Man rogue | 88% | Favored | ||
| Tombstone Spider-Man rogue | 77% | Favored | ||
| Boomerang Spider-Man rogue | 94% | Favored | ||
| The Spot Spider-Man rogue | 51% | Toss-up | ||
| Jackal Spider-Man rogue | 77% | Favored | ||
| Hydro-Man Spider-Man rogue | 67% | Favored | ||
| Beetle Spider-Man rogue | 83% | Favored | ||
| Prowler Spider-Man rogue | 94% | Favored | ||
| Kindred Spider-Man rogue | 22% | Underdog | −2: Emotional pressure once took his powers away, so a mind-game specialist has an opening.; +2: Train-stopping strength and stamina keep him standing against heavy hitters. | |
| Hammerhead Spider-Man rogue | 77% | Favored | ||
| Tarantula Spider-Man rogue | 77% | Favored | ||
| Doctor Doom Marvel villain | 7% | Long shot | ||
| God Emperor Doom Marvel villain | 1% | Long shot | −2: Emotional pressure once took his powers away, so a mind-game specialist has an opening. | |
| Thanos Marvel villain | 1% | Long shot | ||
| Magneto Marvel villain | 14% | Long shot | +3: Organic webbing: there are no steel web-shooters for a magnetic opponent to seize. | |
| Loki Marvel villain | 12% | Long shot | −2: Emotional pressure once took his powers away, so a mind-game specialist has an opening. | |
| Red Skull Marvel villain | 72% | Favored | ||
| Juggernaut Marvel villain | 31% | Underdog | ||
| Mephisto Marvel villain | 2% | Long shot | −2: Emotional pressure once took his powers away, so a mind-game specialist has an opening.; +2: Train-stopping strength and stamina keep him standing against heavy hitters. | |
| Bullseye Marvel villain | 61% | Favored | ||
| Taskmaster Marvel villain | 51% | Toss-up | ||
| Ultron Marvel villain | 10% | Long shot | ||
| Captain America Hero | 51% | Toss-up | ||
| Iron Man Hero | 33% | Underdog | +2: Train-stopping strength and stamina keep him standing against heavy hitters. | |
| Wolverine Hero | 41% | Toss-up | ||
| Daredevil Hero | 72% | Favored | ||
| Deadpool Hero | 41% | Toss-up | ||
| Punisher Hero | 77% | Favored | ||
| Hulk Hero | 3% | Long shot | ||
| Black Panther Hero | 36% | Underdog |
Matchup modifiers
Adjustments on top of the overall rating, in points (25 points is about the gap between a 50% and a 73% fight).
- +3 against metal-armored foes. Organic webbing: there are no steel web-shooters for a magnetic opponent to seize.
- +2 against Doctor Octopus. He has fought an Otto Octavius before and knows how tentacles move.
- +2 against Green Goblin. He has survived Norman's glider and pumpkin bombs before.
- +3 against Sandman. He has beaten a Sandman with water.
- +4 against Venom. He has beaten Venom by turning sound on the symbiote.
- −2 against telepaths or illusion casters. Emotional pressure once took his powers away, so a mind-game specialist has an opening.
- +2 against strength at least 7, strength at most 8. Train-stopping strength and stamina keep him standing against heavy hitters.
Other Spider-Men
- Peter ParkerEarth-616 comics
- Miles MoralesEarth-616 comics
- Ben ReillyEarth-616 comics
- Superior Spider-ManEarth-616 comics
- Black-suit PeterEarth-616 comics
- Iron Spider PeterEarth-616 comics
- Cosmic Spider-ManEarth-616 comics
- Spider-WomanEarth-616 comics
- SilkEarth-616 comics
- Ultimate PeterAlternate comics
- Ultimate Peter (2024)Alternate comics
- Spider-GwenAlternate comics
- Spider-Man 2099Alternate comics
- Spider-Man NoirAlternate comics
- Spider-HamAlternate comics
- Spider-PunkAlternate comics
- Garfield's PeterFilm
- Holland's PeterFilm
- Spider-Verse MilesFilm
- Spider-Verse GwenFilm
- Peter B. ParkerFilm
- 1994 animated PeterTV and animation
- Spectacular PeterTV and animation
- Insomniac PeterVideo games
- Insomniac MilesVideo games