SpiderOddsWho would win? Fan-made fight guide

Spider-Man version · Alternate comics

Peter Parker (Spider-Man Noir, Earth-90214)

A Depression-era Peter who got his powers from a spider idol and fights the mob in 1930s New York.

Debut: Spider-Man Noir #1 (2009).

Against the 49 opponents on this site, Spider-Man Noir is favored in 23 fights, a toss-up in 11, the underdog in 6 and a long shot in 9. Against the whole original Sinister Six at once: 15%. Against all six one after another: 5%. Overall, this version is rated −2 points against classic Peter Parker.

About this Spider-Man

Spider-Man Noir was created by David Hine, Fabrice Sapolsky and Carmine Di Giandomenico in Spider-Man Noir #1 (2009): a 1930s Peter Parker in Depression-era New York who gains his powers from a spider-god idol. Unlike most Spider-Men, he carries guns. Nicolas Cage voiced him in Into the Spider-Verse.

Fight rules: both fighters at their peak, no preparation, no allies, only their own powers and personal gear. A win is a knockout, a restraint they can't escape, or a forced surrender. The percentages are fan estimates, not official information.

Powers

Spider strength, agility and spider-sense from a mystical spider-god source.

Gear

Pistols and a trench coat. He uses the guns when he decides it's necessary.

Signature feats

Brought down the Goblin and his crime empire in his world.

Weaknesses

No modern tech.

Fighting style

Hard-boiled, quiet and willing to shoot.

Power set

Stats

StatSpider-Man NoirClassic Peter
Strength66
Speed66
Agility910
Durability66
Size44
Fighting skill67
Intelligence67
Ranged attack53

Odds against every opponent

Spider-Man Noir's chance of winning each one-on-one fight. Each name links to the full matchup.

OpponentSpidey winsBarOutcomeMatchup modifier
Doctor Octopus
Original Sinister Six
53%Toss-up
Vulture
Original Sinister Six
86%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Electro
Original Sinister Six
53%Toss-up
Kraven the Hunter
Original Sinister Six
53%Toss-up
Mysterio
Original Sinister Six
76%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Sandman
Original Sinister Six
53%Toss-up
Green Goblin
Spider-Man rogue
58%Toss-up
Hobgoblin
Spider-Man rogue
63%Favored
Venom
Spider-Man rogue
38%Underdog
Carnage
Spider-Man rogue
28%Underdog
Kingpin
Spider-Man rogue
79%Favored
Lizard
Spider-Man rogue
58%Toss-up
Rhino
Spider-Man rogue
68%Favored
Scorpion
Spider-Man rogue
68%Favored
Shocker
Spider-Man rogue
84%Favored
Chameleon
Spider-Man rogue
90%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Mister Negative
Spider-Man rogue
63%Favored
Morbius
Spider-Man rogue
68%Favored
Morlun
Spider-Man rogue
14%Long shot
Black Cat
Spider-Man rogue
90%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Tombstone
Spider-Man rogue
79%Favored
Boomerang
Spider-Man rogue
95%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
The Spot
Spider-Man rogue
56%Toss-up+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Jackal
Spider-Man rogue
81%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Hydro-Man
Spider-Man rogue
68%Favored
Beetle
Spider-Man rogue
84%Favored
Prowler
Spider-Man rogue
95%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Kindred
Spider-Man rogue
24%Underdog
Hammerhead
Spider-Man rogue
79%Favored
Tarantula
Spider-Man rogue
79%Favored
Doctor Doom
Marvel villain
7%Long shot
God Emperor Doom
Marvel villain
1%Long shot
Thanos
Marvel villain
1%Long shot
Magneto
Marvel villain
14%Long shot
Loki
Marvel villain
14%Long shot
Red Skull
Marvel villain
76%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Juggernaut
Marvel villain
33%Underdog
Mephisto
Marvel villain
2%Long shot
Bullseye
Marvel villain
66%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Taskmaster
Marvel villain
56%Toss-up+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Ultron
Marvel villain
11%Long shot
Captain America
Hero
53%Toss-up
Iron Man
Hero
33%Underdog
Wolverine
Hero
43%Toss-up
Daredevil
Hero
76%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Deadpool
Hero
43%Toss-up
Punisher
Hero
81%Favored+3: He carries pistols, and a bullet ends it against an opponent without superhuman toughness.
Hulk
Hero
4%Long shot
Black Panther
Hero
38%Underdog

Matchup modifiers

Adjustments on top of the overall rating, in points (25 points is about the gap between a 50% and a 73% fight).

Other Spider-Men

Further reading